Echo and Narcissus at John Rylands Library: Mirror, mirror

Polly Checkland Harding
Photo of a mirror inscribed with words, with a woman's reflection in it

Echo and Narcissus at John Rylands Library uses beautiful, handheld mirrors to look again at women in literature.

It’s amazing how often we look back at old stories to say something new. To say something twice, in a way: both echoing the tale as it was, and finding fresh life in it for now. In a new exhibition at Manchester’s John Rylands Library, artist Carol Sommer has used the Greek myth of Echo and Narcissus to think about literature’s heroines – to reflect on how, and by whom, they’ve been represented.

Lined up in flat glass cases are characterful, handheld mirrors, each beautifully inscribed with a quotation from a novel. The pools of silvered glass gesture towards Narcissus, eternally fixed on his own reflection, while Echo can be heard in the repeated lines from books. Each mirror is dedicated to the person it describes – a portrait, if you will, but not one that’s at all straightforward.

“A woman who is nothing but the look that sees him”

For instance: “The most attractive of all his parent’s friends” is “To Mrs Robinson” from The Graduate. It’s a wry, backhanded line with which to characterise her; as you lean over and peer at the mirror, and yourself, you realise that this is not, perhaps, how most people would choose to be described. Others, like Madame Bovary’s mirror, are similarly loaded (Flaubert’s heroine has the line “All surface but no feeling” dedicated to her) – few, in fact, feel uncomplicated in their gaze.

There’s irony at work, like the line “all surface and no feeling” on Madame Bovary’s mirror. To Inez from No Exit by Jean-Paul Satre is the line “a woman who is nothing but the look that sees him.” Many question how their characters are seen by men – and, in a broader way, point to a historic approach to both female authors and characters. The beauty of this exhibition is how much it yields: it’s incredibly layered for a rather unassuming installation.

It’s also quite lovely to look at. The mirrors, some crisp, others becoming blinded with fissures through age, all reflect the Historic Reading room’s lights and its high, intricate windows. Echo and Narcissus is a quiet, contemplative piece of free, public art; you might not spend more than half an hour of reflection there, but you’re likely to come out seeing books, and yourself, differently.

Culture Guides

Cinema

Music and movies intersect in our latest guide to cinema in Manchester and the North.

Exhibitions

Like the 58th Venice Biennale which opened earlier this May, our latest pick of exhibitions across the north also has a strong ecological bent.

Quays Culture Summer Festival

Families

We can almost smell the summer and have sniffed out the best family things to do in Manchester and across the North.

Poet Rebecca Tamás at That's What She Said.

Literature

We’re in full festival swing with MIF’s first focus on live literature, and plenty of poetry and prose cropping up in the ‘burbs.

Music

Some of the world’s most exciting producers are heading to Manchester and the north in the coming months. Read about them here.

Theatre in Manchester

Theatre

Packed with experimental festival performances, an award-winning musical, feisty standup comedy and much more…it’s our new theatre guide.

Hatch

Food and Drink in Manchester and the North

Discover the best food and drink that the North has to offer in our expert guide to food and drink in Manchester and beyond.

tours and activities

Tours and Activities

Try something different in May with our round up of the month’s alternative Tours and Activities in Manchester.